We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Ice Fishing Reels 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

Pflueger President Spinning Reel, Size 40 Fishing Reel, Right/Left Handle Position, Graphite Body and Rotor, Corrosion-Resistant, Aluminum Spool, Front Drag System, Blue

The Pflueger President Spinning Reel is a solid choice for anyone looking to enhance their ice fishing experience. This reel is designed with a lightweight graphite body and rotor, making it easy to handle during long fishing sessions. Weighing in at just 0.86 pounds, it's comfortable for both right and left-handed users, thanks to its ambidextrous handle design. With a gear ratio of 5.2:1 and a retrieval rate of 31.6 inches per crank, this reel provides good control and fast action, essential for catching fish in icy waters.

One of its standout features is the sealed oil felt front drag system, with a maximum drag of 14 pounds. This helps tire out fish effectively, allowing for a smoother reeling process. The 10 ball bearing system and Instant Anti-Reverse feature contribute to its smooth operation, which can be a big advantage when you’re trying to land a catch in challenging conditions.

In terms of line capacity, it can accommodate various monofilament sizes, allowing for optimal casting distance and accuracy. This flexibility is beneficial for adapting to different fishing environments. While the reel excels in performance and value, some anglers might find the drag system not as refined as higher-end models. Also, because it’s made of graphite, it may not offer the same level of durability against rough handling as some metal-bodied reels, particularly in extreme ice fishing conditions. The Pflueger President presents a fantastic option for casual to intermediate ice fishermen seeking a reliable, affordable spinning reel that balances performance with ease of use, delivering great value for its price.

Customer Highlights

A summary of real customer reviews to highlight what shoppers are saying!
Drag System
Extreme quality and a very smooth drag make this reel stand out.
Material and Build Quality
Smooth, sturdy, and dependable, offering great value compared to other brands.
#2

Pflueger President XT Spinning Reel, Size 20 Fishing Reel, Right/Left Handle Position, Aluminum Spool, Front Drag System

The Pflueger President XT Spinning Reel is a solid choice for ice fishing enthusiasts looking for a reliable and lightweight reel. This reel stands out with its upgraded components, enhancing performance while maintaining a modest weight of only 0.35 pounds, making it easy to handle during long fishing sessions. The aluminum spool and main shaft add to its strength and durability, which is critical for ice fishing conditions.

With a gear ratio of 5.2:1, the reel recovers 20.7 inches of line per crank, meaning you can reel in your catch quickly and efficiently. The front drag system, with a maximum drag of 6 pounds, is beneficial in tiring out the fish before reeling it in, which is often necessary in ice fishing scenarios. The line capacity is well-suited for different fishing needs, accommodating various line sizes (200 yards of 2 lb, 100 yards of 4 lb, and 80 yards of 6 lb mono). This versatility allows anglers to adjust according to the size of the fish they are targeting.

While the 7-ball bearing system provides smooth operation, it may not be as robust as some competitors with higher bearing counts, which can affect performance under heavy use. Additionally, the maximum drag of 6 pounds might be limiting for anglers targeting larger fish. The carbon fiber handle and rubber cork knobs ensure comfort, but some users may prefer a more textured grip, especially in cold conditions. Also, the sizing (20) may limit its appeal to those looking for larger reels for bigger catches.

Customer Highlights

A summary of real customer reviews to highlight what shoppers are saying!
Type of Reel
The Pflueger President Series has been a go-to for ultra-light, light, and light-medium reels for over 10 years, praised for their reliability and longevity.
Drag System
A great addition to the freshwater fishing collection, casting great with sturdy bail and smooth drag.
Material and Build Quality
These reels have never failed or caused any problems, even under the abuse of inexperienced users, standing the test of time.
Handle Design
The cork grip on the handle is comfortable and the reel has an attractive appearance with quality drag components.
#3

HANDING M1 Spinning Reel, Freshwater Fishing Reels Spinning, 9+1 Ball Bearings, 26.5LBs Max Drag, 5.2:1 Gear Ratio, Graphite Frame, CNC Aluminum Spool, 500 to 5000 Series, Handle Interchangeable

The HANDING M1 Spinning Reel is a versatile and robust choice for freshwater fishing, including ice fishing. It boasts a 5.2:1 gear ratio, which offers a good balance between speed and power, suitable for handling various freshwater species. The reel features a 3-layer woven drag system capable of 26.5 lbs of maximum drag, providing significant stopping power, making it ideal for battling larger fish in colder conditions.

The 9+1 stainless steel ball bearings ensure smooth operation and the anti-reverse function helps secure your catch effectively. Constructed with a lightweight graphite frame and a CNC aluminum spool, the reel is both durable and sensitive, enhancing the fishing experience. The interchangeable handle adds convenience for both right and left-handed users.

However, users should be aware that while the reel's lightweight design is beneficial for ease of use, it might not be as sturdy as some heavier, more solidly built reels in very harsh conditions. Additionally, its line capacity might be limiting for those targeting larger, more aggressive fish that require more line. The HANDING M1 is a dependable option for most recreational freshwater and ice fishing scenarios.

Customer Highlights

A summary of real customer reviews to highlight what shoppers are saying!
Type of Reel
For the price point, quite a decent spinning reel.
Drag System
Quality seems great, super smooth, drag seems smooth and progressive.
Line Capacity
Used on a 10' crappie pole with 30lb braid and worked great. Very nice reel.
Material and Build Quality
Relatively heavy for their size, with the 4000 size being quite a monster, suitable for larger gamefish.

Buying Guide for the Best Ice Fishing Reels

Choosing the right ice fishing reel is crucial for a successful and enjoyable fishing experience. Ice fishing reels are designed to withstand the cold and provide smooth operation in freezing conditions. When selecting an ice fishing reel, it's important to consider several key specifications to ensure you get the best fit for your needs. Understanding these specs will help you make an informed decision and enhance your ice fishing adventures.
Type of ReelThere are three main types of ice fishing reels: spinning reels, inline reels, and baitcasting reels. Spinning reels are versatile and easy to use, making them a popular choice for beginners. Inline reels reduce line twist and are great for light lures and finesse fishing. Baitcasting reels offer precision and control, ideal for targeting larger fish. Choose the type based on your experience level and the type of fish you plan to catch.
Gear RatioThe gear ratio indicates how many times the spool rotates with one turn of the handle. A higher gear ratio (e.g., 6:1) means faster line retrieval, which is useful for active fishing and quickly bringing in your catch. A lower gear ratio (e.g., 4:1) provides more torque, making it easier to reel in larger fish. Consider the type of fish and your fishing style when selecting the gear ratio.
Drag SystemThe drag system controls the resistance a fish feels when pulling on the line. A smooth and reliable drag system is essential for preventing line breakage and ensuring you can handle strong fish. Look for reels with adjustable drag settings and high-quality materials. If you target larger fish, opt for a reel with a higher maximum drag capacity.
Line CapacityLine capacity refers to the amount of fishing line the reel can hold. It's usually measured in yards and varies based on the line's thickness. For ice fishing, you typically don't need a reel with a large line capacity since you're fishing in a confined area. However, ensure the reel can hold enough line for the depth of water you'll be fishing in and the size of the fish you're targeting.
Material and Build QualityThe material and build quality of the reel affect its durability and performance in cold conditions. Reels made from high-quality materials like aluminum or graphite are lightweight, strong, and resistant to corrosion. Ensure the reel has a sturdy construction and can withstand the harsh environment of ice fishing. A well-built reel will last longer and provide a better fishing experience.
Handle DesignThe handle design impacts comfort and ease of use, especially when wearing gloves in cold weather. Look for reels with ergonomic handles that provide a good grip and are easy to turn. Some reels come with oversized handles or knobs, which can be beneficial for maintaining control and comfort during long fishing sessions. Choose a handle design that feels comfortable and suits your fishing style.

FAQ